Avid Media Composer and Adobe Premiere Pro are two of the film editing community’s tallest giants. Both are considered leaders, boasting incredible palettes of tools and tweaks to help you polish your footage quickly and precisely.
Although you’ll find opinionated users on both sides, there are a lot of similarities between the two. Many of the differences relate to the kinds of projects and teams each is designed for as well as the workflow style that you as a user prefer.
Avid Media Composer Overview
Media Composer is renowned as the industry standard for professional video editing. Launched in 1989 as the first nonlinear professional video editing software, Media Composer remains one of the most advanced editing platforms.
At first glance, the interface reveals a plethora of commands and controls, signifying its expansive capabilities. It’s no surprise that this customizability makes Media Composer the go-to video editing software for many award-winning Hollywood filmmakers.
Once acquainted with the configurable panel-based workspace and customizable keyboard-based editing, the scope of what you can achieve with your footage is boundless.
Key Features and Strength for Avid Media Composer
- Advanced Trimming Tools and Script-Based Editing: Allows precision and efficiency in every edit
- Media Management: Offers superior management of media files, ensuring efficient organization and retrieval
- Multicam Editing: Allows for simultaneous editing of footage from multiple cameras, facilitating a smoother editing experience
- High-Res Workflows: Supports editing in high resolutions, ensuring pristine quality and detail preservation
- ScriptSync AI: Automates dialog search and sync, facilitates the creation of scripts from clips, manages transcriptions efficiently, and detects multiple languages automatically
- PhraseFind AI: Provides AI-powered dialog search, indexes dialog-driven media, creates transcripts automatically, and integrates seamlessly with Media Composer platforms
- Avid | Edit On Demand: Provides access to a virtual editing suite in the cloud, including cloud-optimized Media Composer software and Avid NEXIS storage
- Avid NEXIS | EDGE: Facilitates ease of remote collaboration and is offered with Media Composer | Enterprise at no additional cost
- New Workspace Layouts: Allow users to easily transition from Adobe Premiere Pro
Try Media Composer For Free
A Brief Overview of Premiere Pro
Premiere Pro was birthed in the 1990s as a QuickTime-based video editor called ReelTime. The software was bought by Adobe while it was still in its unfinished beta stage and quickly renamed to Premiere.
The first version had 24 effects and could handle a maximum resolution width of 1024 pixels and up to 10 frames per second. The cheapest editing software available at the time, its user base grew quickly, and its second version shipped with better video format compatibility and more than twice the effects.
The software went through a complete code overwrite in 2003 and was rebooted as Premiere Pro. In 2005, Adobe introduced their Creative Suite Production Studio, containing After Effects, Photoshop and other tools to expand Premiere Pro’s integration options. In 2011, Adobe stopped selling physical software and began marketing their Creative Cloud, which would offer broader services, regular updates and more streamlined integration.
Key Features and Strengths of Adobe Premiere Pro
Some key features of Adobe Premiere Pro include:
- The Creative Cloud is a comprehensive video editing ecosystem with cohesive integration between its apps, specializing in video effects, post-production, mobile editing, photo editing, etc.
- Fast, responsive interface helps make you more efficient and productive
- Highly customizable workspaces
- Import video files directly with no transcoding
- Broad selection of built-in features, effects, titles and color correction tools
- Also lots of third-party tutorials, templates, plugins, effects, etc. that you can find online
- Exhaustive format support able to import or export from almost any codec or camera available
Comparison: Avid Media Composer vs. Premiere Pro
Interface and User Experience
Media Composer is a bit more challenging to learn to use than Premiere Pro. This is precisely because of its more technical features and broader toolset.
If you’re new to video editing, Media Composer’s more customizable workspace might make you feel frustrated at first. Even though you’ll have the power to edit like a god, some of the most useful tools can be hard to locate and understand. When error messages pop up, they can be almost indecipherable to newbies.
Premiere feels more intuitive right out of the gate, with tools and features that are easier to find and start using. The interface is geared more toward new users and smaller teams, and the workflow is smoother and quicker, although you’ll find a few more bugs than in Media Composer, the top Adobe Premiere alternative.
Media Composer lets users tweak their workspace preferences and save those changes to separate profiles. It then applies these automatically to each new project the user creates. The timeline is also much larger than Premiere’s by default, which makes it easier to edit larger, more complicated projects.
Premiere can’t save each user’s preferences, but it does come with lots of workspace presets that you can use or just scroll through and steal the best customization ideas others have come up with. You’ll also find a large variety of free Premiere tutorials online from users of every skill level demonstrating every tool and feature.
While Adobe’s cacophony of third-party help and online tutorials are great for getting started, Media Composer comes with solid built-in assistance and a professional workforce adept at using MC in collaborative, cross-department workflows. This workforce support can be more helpful for real-world situations.
Organization and Media Management
Media Composer uses a transcoding workflow that requires preparation time during ingesting to convert the media to an Avid-specific format. However, this process provides a much more stable editing experience with higher quality media across different levels of computer hardware. This reliability makes Media Composer better for time-sensitive projects.
Once you’ve put together a final sequence in Media Composer, you can use the consolidate tool to get rid of all your unused material. These transcoding and consolidation features make it much easier to share projects with your team and give Media Composer better backward compatibility with projects made in previous versions.
Premiere workflows tend to start with editing raw media directly imported to the project. While this means faster preparation, it can lead to performance reliability issues across stations and opens the door for offline media.
Video Editing
Media Composer puts the keyboard front and center with most edits and options accessible from simple keyboard shortcuts. This can be a bit slower at first but ends up being much faster than editing mostly with the mouse.
This keyboard-first policy makes Media Composer’s trim mode faster and more powerful than almost any other video editing software. You’ll find specific trimming options for any kind of insert, cut, extract or splice, and you’ll even be able to trim multiple tracks at once.
Premiere makes it easy to get started quickly with mouse-based editing. If you’re a new user, this gives you less incentive to figure out keyboard editing and can end up making you a slower editor. Thanks to its Photoshop integration and direct file import, Premiere also excels at bringing still photos to life.
Effects and Graphics
Both Media Composer and Premiere Pro are awash with built-in effects. Premiere has a slight edge in quantity, but Media Composer’s effects generally come with more automation and technical detail.
There’s almost always a quick automated option for anything you want to do with an effect in Media Composer. Premiere’s effects are mostly built around manual keyframing, which can be excruciatingly laborious. Its integration with After Effects, though, allows you to adjust effect settings externally and skip all the intermediate rendering.
Adobe’s large DIY community also gives Premiere the edge in free third-party plugins. The extra plugins available for Media Composer are mostly professionally made and definitely not cheap.
If you’re a color scientist, color correction and grading is more thorough in Media Composer. Its endless graphs and waveforms help you clearly visualize your footage’s brightness, warmth and individual color channels and balances. Its adjustment curves, allowing you to bend your desired color or brightness setting toward or away from certain values, give you more control than Premiere’s simpler sliders and wheels.
Premiere’s text and title tools are powerful and easy to use, but its keyframe-based motion tracking is slow. Media Composer’s title tool is a bit too basic and its Marquee tool is a bit too complicated, but the program handles 3D text well and comes with automatic motion tracking.
Audio Editing
Media Composer wins the high-end audio editing wars hands down thanks to Media Composer’s tight integration with the audio editing industry standard, Pro Tools. Pro Tools gives you the superpowers of a sound engineer with some of the world’s most advanced mixing and EQ tools, automatic syncing and a forest of audio effects.
Premiere has some genuinely useful audio editing features too, but these pale next to Pro Tools’ functionality and depth.
Collaboration
Media Composer has become the film industry’s go-to media editing software in part because of its unrivaled collaboration capabilities. Editors of massive, high-budget productions can easily and quickly share projects with remote team members, apply changes to all users of a project and move files between projects.
The bin locking feature can prevent accidents by allowing team members to block overwrites to the parts of the project they’re currently working on. Media Composer’s Enterprise version includes a number of additional cloud-based production and distributed processing tools.
Premiere Pro’s collaboration options are still more limited and not as stable.
Save and Export
The autosave function in Media Composer works in the background while you edit, storing multiple copies of your bin at 15-minute intervals that you can restore in an emergency. Premiere interrupts your work every time it wants to autosave.
When your video is ready, Media Composer can export it to any standard broadcast resolution and frame rate. Premiere has broader and more specific export options and settings that work better for YouTube and other social media sites.
Ecosystem
Media Composer’s Ultimate and Enterprise versions include some extremely useful editing, organization and collaboration tools, but overall these are not as diverse or powerful as Adobe’s Creative Cloud.
Adobe’s ecosystem is wider and has a simpler workflow between specialized apps that excel in photo editing, post-production, graphics and effects, animation and more. Premiere Pro also has a massive DIY ecosystem that is constantly churning out tools, plugins, templates, effects, tutorials and other resources from helpful users.
Budget
Both Media Composer and Premiere Pro offer subscription-based purchases with monthly and yearly plans. Avid’s pricing structure is generally a bit higher than Adobe’s, making it a significant investment geared toward professional production houses. Premiere Pro has slightly lower upfront costs, making it more affordable for individual content creators and smaller production teams.
Why You Might Prefer Avid Media Composer
Pros
- Considered the go-to video editing software in the filmmaking industry with a large professional community
- The closed MXF system is exceptional at media management, reducing offline media problems and large asset lag
- More control over editing, effects and tools
- Keyboard-first control and efficient trim mode for faster editing
- Teaches important editing basics to form well-rounded foundation
- Easier collaboration and more stability when editing large projects with multiple remote editors
- Integration with Pro Tools gives you the world’s most powerful audio editing capabilities
Cons
- Interface can feel complicated to beginners
- Fewer and more expensive extra plugins
- Applying motion to photos can be tricky
- Fewer export options and less compatibility with YouTube and other social media
- Smaller ecosystem
- Smaller DIY community with fewer third-party effects, plugins, tutorials and other tools
- Slightly more expensive
Why You Might Prefer Adobe Premiere Pro
- Geared more toward individual content creators and small production teams
- User-friendly interface easier for first-time editors to learn
- More built-in basic effects
- Comprehensive ecosystem with simple integration
- Large DIY community with lots of third-party effects, plugins, tutorials, etc.
- More export options and settings
- Slightly cheaper
Cons
- No individual user profiles
- Direct import can cause offline media problems if you’re not careful
- Can be slow and buggy when working with large projects and assets
- Manual keyframing can be slow
- Less powerful audio editing
- Autosave interrupts work
- Collaboration a little less stable
Choosing the Right Editing Tool
Media Composer is the best video editing software if you’re a professional filmmaking team looking for a high-end all-in-one editing solution for large, collaborative projects.
Adobe Premiere Pro’s cheaper initial cost, intuitive interface, large amateur community and comprehensive ecosystem make it one of the best video editors for DIY editors and smaller teams.
If you’d like to get started on the path to becoming a world-class filmmaker, click here to try Avid’s Media Composer Ultimate for 30 days completely free.
Adobe, After Effects, Creative Cloud, Creative Suite, Photoshop, and Premiere Pro are either trademarks or registered trademarks of Adobe in the United States and/or other countries.
Try Media Composer For Free
